December 12, 2010

5. Contra / Vampire Weekend


Contra

Vampire Weekend has more rhythm, funk, syncopation, and flow than nine out of every ten rappers. The Columbia-grads put on two great shows this year and sounded tight, inspired, and fresh. Contra is a natural extension of the band's phenomenal debut, and the album shines after getting waxed with additional eccentricities. These guys are keepers.

Thankfully, the band's sophomore album stays faithful to their sonic identity while also expanding into varied musical spaces. The ebullient production allows the band to redefine their intellectual indie-pop with genre-defying songs. Contra is mature, perhaps more subtle in parts than its predecessor, but it never sacrifices its sense of playfulness and, notably, its sense of joy.

Ezra Koenig's literate allusions to the obscure or arch-elite continue to impress. His observations are as sharp as the band's precise and inimitable musical direction. Best line on the album (or maybe any album this year): "The little stairway / A little piece of carpet / A pair of mirrors that are facing one another / Out in both directions / A thousand little Julias / That come together / In the middle of Manhattan."

Opening track "Horchata" is the perfect late-winter antidote, while "White Sky" breaks through the cloud cover with a series of chorus yelps as only Koenig can deliver. (The keyboards alone on these tracks are worth paying full admission). Other favorites: the escapist electro-violins of "Run," the ultra-fast drum fills and prickly guitars of "Cousins," the sing-along chorus and bridge of "Giving Up the Gun," and the reggae-fied nostalgia of "Diplomat's Son."

Some misguided listeners have questioned the band's authenticity. After all, didn't they get an Ivy-league education? (Yes.) Didn't they grow up in upper-class privilege? (Sort of.) Didn't they exploit globe-trotting musical references by bringing them to the masses? (And your point?) The D Man has little time for identity politics when listening to music, especially music this diverse and refreshing. When assessing artistic merit, socio-economics never held much sway for The D Man. So Van Gogh was poor. So Picasso was rich. Interesting, no doubt. But that does not necessarily mean that "Sunflowers" is greater than "Guernica."

Likewise, if Ezra Koenig can so convincingly break down Congolese soukous inside an Upper West Side narrative, it makes little difference what high school he went to--The D Man will be listening. Indeed, few complain when Lil' Wayne exploits his quasi-surroundings for serious monetary gain, and he doesn't even write compelling songs, something Koenig seems incapable of doing. But when your skin color is of the paler variety, heaven forbid you co-opt culture and music that moves you. You're called a cloy.

But I digress. Vampire Weekend seems to have few musical horizons, especially when considering how effective--and comfortable--the band is when playing with electro-pop, new wave, Afro-ryhthms, punk, and whatever else catches their fancy. The D Man's only advice: Go on, go on, go on.

2 comments:

Gavin said...

Does the fact that Tommy Hilfiger and Honda use the same Vampire Weekend song ("Holiday") in their new commercials cheapen the album? http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3B15j9Xs_CE I want to punch everyone in the Tommy Hilfiger commercial (including the dog) - it's only redeeming quality is that it reminds me of Royal Tennenbaums and Rushmore. Honda commercial here: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Xcbo1Z2LsrM&playnext=1&list=PL2E4B5BE7AB508B89&index=14

The D Man said...

No.

Does the fact that Picasso sold his pieces to upscale collectors cheapen his paintings? Does the fact that Cormac McCarthy talked with Oprah (and allowed her seal of approval on his book) cheapen his literature? Does the fact that the Coen Brothers shoe-horned their new movie into a PG-13 rating to reach a wider audience cheapen their film?

Art and commerce have been strange bedfellows since people started scratching things on caves. Can commerce affect my perception of the art? Sure. Would I like artists to make wise decisions? Absolutely. But will I begrudge them from making some coin from their praiseworthy efforts? No.

The D Man is a firm believer in judging the intrinsic aesthetic merit of any given endeavor, even if that is an unachievable ideal for some. While it may be difficult to divorce such judgment from the marketplace, and, indeed, some authentic efforts are specifically designed for the marketplace, the fact that Vampire Weekend licensed "Holiday" for obvious commercials gives me little heartburn. The D Man would advise them to do the same thing.

(And, truly, "Holiday" just came on a radio ad for Honda as I typed this response. Still not swayed.)